Poor QB Succession Plan: The Kirk Cousins Case Study
The NFL is a brutal business. Nowhere is this more evident than in the constant churn at the quarterback position. Finding a franchise quarterback is the holy grail, and teams often struggle to adequately plan for the inevitable day when their starter moves on – either through retirement, injury, or free agency. The case of Kirk Cousins highlights the pitfalls of a poorly executed quarterback succession plan, offering valuable lessons for NFL teams.
The Cousins Conundrum: A Decade of Uncertainty
Kirk Cousins' career trajectory has been a fascinating, and somewhat frustrating, study in quarterbacking. Drafted in the fourth round by the Washington Redskins in 2012, he initially served as a backup. His eventual rise to prominence, however, wasn't a smooth transition planned by the Redskins. It was more a consequence of circumstances and a lack of foresight in developing a clear succession plan.
The Redskins, for years, seemed content to let Cousins develop slowly, without a clear path to becoming the undisputed starter. This hesitant approach created a period of uncertainty, both for Cousins and for the franchise. While he eventually became a starter, the team never truly invested in grooming a potential successor, leaving them vulnerable when Cousins’ contract situation became contentious.
Missed Opportunities and Lack of Development
The Redskins' failure to develop a legitimate quarterback behind Cousins is arguably their biggest misstep. Instead of strategically drafting and developing a young quarterback, they opted for short-term solutions and failed to effectively utilize their resources. This lack of foresight led to a critical void when Cousins' contract expired and he ultimately left via free agency, leaving the Redskins scrambling for answers.
The Ripple Effect: Lessons for NFL Teams
The Kirk Cousins saga serves as a cautionary tale for NFL teams. Several key takeaways emerge:
-
Proactive Planning is Crucial: Teams must have a proactive, long-term plan for the quarterback position. This involves consistently scouting, drafting, and developing young quarterbacks, regardless of the current starter's performance.
-
Don't Neglect the Backup: Investing in a capable backup isn't just about having a replacement; it's about fostering competition and providing opportunities for development. A strong backup can push the starter and be ready to step in seamlessly if needed.
-
Contract Negotiations Matter: The Redskins' handling of Cousins' contract negotiations showcased the potential for conflict. Teams must understand that even star quarterbacks' contracts expire and plan accordingly to avoid a repeat of the costly free agency scramble.
-
Long-Term Vision Over Short-Term Gains: Prioritizing short-term success over the long-term development of a franchise quarterback often backfires. Building a strong team requires a balance between winning now and ensuring sustainable success in the future.
Conclusion: Learning from Cousins' Journey
The Kirk Cousins experience offers invaluable insights into the complexities of managing the quarterback position in the NFL. By analyzing the Redskins' mistakes, other teams can learn to create a more robust and sustainable strategy for quarterback succession, preventing a similar period of instability and uncertainty. A well-executed succession plan is not just about finding a replacement; it’s about ensuring long-term success and building a winning franchise.
