Schottenheimer: A Viable Cowboys Head Coach?
The Dallas Cowboys, a team steeped in history and perpetually chasing a Super Bowl victory, find themselves once again searching for the right leader. With coaching changes a recurring theme in recent years, the question on many fans' minds is: Could Marty Schottenheimer be a viable option? While his coaching career concluded some time ago, examining his strengths and weaknesses reveals a complex picture. This article delves into whether Schottenheimer, were he still coaching, would be a suitable fit for "America's Team."
The Case for Schottenheimer
Schottenheimer's NFL coaching career, spanning over two decades, boasts an impressive regular season record. His consistent ability to build winning teams, often with less-than-stellar rosters, speaks volumes about his coaching acumen. This consistency is a stark contrast to the Cowboys' recent rollercoaster of seasons. Let's look at his key strengths:
-
Disciplined Approach: Schottenheimer was known for his meticulous preparation and disciplined approach to the game. This focus on fundamentals and execution could provide the Cowboys with the stability they often lack. His teams were notoriously well-prepared and rarely out-coached.
-
Player Development: He had a knack for identifying and developing talent. While not always known for flashy offenses, his teams consistently played above expectations, a testament to his player development skills. This would be crucial for a Cowboys team with a young and developing core.
-
Strong Defensive Foundations: Many of Schottenheimer's teams prioritized a strong defense, a philosophy that could resonate well with the Cowboys' defensive-minded fanbase. Building a strong defensive identity could be a significant step towards long-term success.
The Case Against Schottenheimer
Despite his impressive regular season record, Schottenheimer's postseason record remains a significant blemish on his legacy. His inability to consistently translate regular season success into playoff victories is a major point of contention for those considering his candidacy. This raises some important questions:
-
Playoff Performance: This is the elephant in the room. His playoff struggles are a matter of record, and the Cowboys, a franchise desperate for playoff success, can't afford to ignore this significant weakness.
-
Offensive Philosophy: His offensive schemes were often criticized for being too conservative, potentially clashing with the Cowboys' desire for a high-powered offense. In today's NFL, offensive innovation is crucial, and Schottenheimer might struggle to keep pace.
-
Modern Game Adaptation: The NFL has evolved significantly since Schottenheimer's last coaching role. The question of whether he could adapt his strategies and philosophy to the modern game's nuances is a legitimate concern.
Conclusion: A Hypothetical Consideration
While Marty Schottenheimer's coaching career is in the past, analyzing his strengths and weaknesses provides valuable insight into the qualities needed for a successful Cowboys head coach. His disciplined approach and talent development skills are undeniable assets, but his playoff record remains a major hurdle. Ultimately, whether he would have been a viable option for the Cowboys is a hypothetical question. His legacy, however, serves as a reminder of the delicate balance between regular season success and the ultimate goal: winning the Super Bowl. The Cowboys need a coach who can consistently win in the regular season and deliver in the playoffs. While Schottenheimer excelled in the former, his shortcomings in the latter remain a significant obstacle.
