Schottenheimer's Cowboys Head Coach Pursuit: A Missed Opportunity?
The 1989 Dallas Cowboys head coaching search remains a fascinating case study in what could have been. The team, mired in mediocrity after the Tom Landry era, sought a fresh face to lead them back to glory. One name that repeatedly surfaces in discussions about this pivotal moment in Cowboys history is Marty Schottenheimer. This article delves into the intricacies of Schottenheimer's pursuit of the Cowboys' head coaching position, examining why he ultimately wasn't chosen and the lasting impact of that decision.
The Context: A Cowboys Team in Transition
The post-Landry Cowboys were a team in desperate need of rejuvenation. Years of consistent, if unspectacular, play had given way to a period of inconsistency and underachievement. The franchise needed a leader who could inspire a change in culture and instill a winning mentality. Enter Marty Schottenheimer, a coach known for his disciplined approach and ability to build strong, competitive teams.
Schottenheimer's Credentials: A Strong Contender
At the time, Schottenheimer had already established himself as a highly respected coach in the NFL. His record with the Cleveland Browns spoke for itself, demonstrating his prowess in developing talent and fostering a winning atmosphere, despite often lacking top-tier talent. His reputation preceded him, making him a compelling candidate for the Cowboys' vacancy.
The Interviews and the Decision: A Twist of Fate?
While specific details of the interview process remain largely undisclosed, it's widely believed that Schottenheimer impressed the Cowboys' ownership and front office. However, ultimately, Jimmy Johnson secured the position. Johnson, with his innovative offensive schemes and charismatic personality, presented a different vision for the franchise, one that proved remarkably successful.
The "What If?" Scenario: Analyzing the Missed Opportunity
Many speculate on what might have been had Schottenheimer been chosen. Would his more conservative, run-heavy style have yielded similar success? While impossible to definitively answer, considering the stark contrast between Schottenheimer's and Johnson's coaching philosophies, it's plausible to suggest a different trajectory for the Cowboys' dynasty. Schottenheimer's focus on strong defense and ground game might have resulted in a less explosive, but potentially more consistently successful team.
The Legacy: A Lesson in Coaching and Franchise Management
The Schottenheimer-Cowboys saga highlights the complexities of NFL head coaching searches. It demonstrates that even the most qualified candidates might not always be the best fit for a particular organization's needs at a specific moment in time. The Cowboys' choice of Johnson ultimately proved to be a brilliant one, but the "what if" surrounding Schottenheimer continues to intrigue and fuel debate among football fans. The story serves as a reminder that success in the NFL often depends on a complex interplay of factors beyond just coaching talent.
